In addition to everything else, Brendan and I went through a bit of a…rough patch in our relationship. “Rough patch” makes it sound like more than it was, but I was genuinely wondering if we were going to make it since I felt like we were too deep into our relationship to be having the issues we were having.
It started at the beginning of the year when Brendan wanted to take a trip to his favorite place to escape the New York City winter. We planned a quick trip to Miami, mostly just to get out of the city, drink more than we should and eat good food. Obviously I did not want to go, but Brendan and I hadn’t spent much quality time together alone with the holidays and everything else going on. So I’d endure Florida for a couple of days for my man.
We landed late on the first night and headed to a little restaurant and sat at their bar to have dinner/drinks. We must have been excited to be away from home and let loose because we started downing espresso martinis like we were getting paid for it. Brendan ordered food for us but I guess I was uninterested and was mainly focused on the fact that there was an iPhone app to control the music in the bar. I immediately downloaded the app and played “Taste” by Tyga (sorry). You know, just really living my best life.
If you’ve been here for a while, then you know I’m a yapper — especially with any random stranger in a bar. Apparently I was sharing the DJing duties with a Nordic looking dude who was sitting one stool away from me at the bar. He was adorable and harmless and could not have been older than 25 years old. Once we realized that we were the only ones in the bar controlling the music, we started talking and he climbed over to the bar stool next to me. He was mostly playing European house music and I’m like, “Your generation just doesn’t understand the cultural impact of Ke$ha!” So we went back and forth playing music and discussing. I was vaguely aware of Brendan’s foot on the back of my barstool and his arm around my waist.
He tapped me and I spun around to face him.
“What are you doing?” Brendan mouthed, looking concerned.
“What? I’m sorry,” I said automatically, not even fully grasping what he was referring to.
“I don’t like that. Stop it,” he said.
“Okay,” I said obediently.
And then I spun my tail back around and started talking to my new friend again! In my defense, Brendan didn’t specify exactly what he didn’t like so how was I supposed to know that he was threatened by a 25 year old stranger?
Brendan paid the bill and we left soon after that. I skipped my happy ass back to the hotel blissfully unaware that Brendan was mad at me. Once we got up to our room, I got undressed and blabbed about how I couldn’t wait to get in bed and sleep so then I could wake up and have breakfast. And then Brendan started going off on me about my behavior.
He’s like, “I can’t believe you acted like that with that dude at the bar. I feel really disrespected.”
I was genuinely so shocked that 1. he was speaking to me like that 2. he was so mad. I was absolutely not flirting with that child — I’d be the first to admit if I was. So Brendan’s reaction seemed to come out of nowhere. And he kept going and going: how he was afraid of this happening and he didn’t want to have to deal with “this” forever and making it seem like this was an obstacle he wasn’t sure if we could overcome. And since he was upset, I was upset and I completely crashed out. I was questioning my actions and trying to think of exactly what I’d done that made Brendan feel so disrespected. Since we’d been drinking so much, I was having trouble recalling the details before Brendan’s mood completely changed. So then I wondered if it was finally time for me to quit drinking once and for all. If it was going to cause this much strife in my relationship, I was willing to do it.
“I don’t even know what I did wrong, I’m sorry,” I sobbed.
“You were all over him. I will not tolerate that. Does this [ring] mean nothing to you?” Brendan said, making me feel horrible. I felt like shit for hurting him and for making him feel insecure about the guy at the bar because he thought I was flirting with him – especially because I wasn’t. Like, if he thought that was flirting, then he didn’t want to see what I was like when I actually was.
And even when I was profusely apologizing and crying, Brendan did not stop or let up like he normally would. Not that my tears should’ve changed how he felt, but usually he always makes me feel better. Nope, he left me to feel guilty and went to sleep without a word and with his back to me. Obviously I was up all night feeling awful that I’d made my man upset.
The next morning, I woke up and Brendan was cuddling me like normal. I felt like I’d been hit by a truck and it took a few moments to remember the fight from the night before. Was it even a fight? I wasn’t even exactly sure how to describe what happened, but I felt emotionally drained and exhausted and was confused that Brendan was spooning me. When I thought about how we left things the previous night before falling asleep, it was hard to imagine easily coming back from that. That’s how bad and out of character it was.
After a while, Brendan must have sensed that I was awake and put a hand on my shoulder/neck – like he does when he wants to kiss.
“What did you want for breakfast?” he asked.
“What?” Breakfast? Who was even thinking about breakfast anymore? “Are you still mad?”
“No,” he said back automatically. “Sorry. I didn’t mean to make you cry last night.”
“Uh, okay. But do you know that I wasn’t flirting with that dude? We were literally just playing music? Is that really why you were mad?”
And then Brendan was just like, “Yeah, maybe I overreacted – oops, tehe – can I have a kiss now?”
At the time, I was just glad that he wasn’t mad at me and that we weren’t fighting anymore. But the more I thought about it, the more I felt resentful that I’d had such an emotional night and he provided no reassurance when I was crashing out and then acted like it wasn’t a big deal.
And maybe that situation was in the back of my mind when, one night a few weeks later, I made Brendan tell me how many girls he hooked up between when his wife broke up with him and when we got together. I assumed it would be zero since the timeframe I was referring to was not very long (just a few months, if you think about it). I hadn’t hooked up with anyone so I assumed he hadn’t either. Like yes, we both moved on fast but it was only because it was with each other – a special circumstance, you know?
“I don’t really think that’s something you need to know,” Brendan said.
So then I bullied begged him until he told me that there were two girls. He had a one night stand (he described it as a ‘spontaneous, one-off thing’) in fucking Miami and then he told me that he had a brief situation with a girl from high who is also mutual friends with his ex-wife.
She was too stunned to speak!
How and when did he even have time to do that? And to be honest, I didn’t think he had it in him. He just doesn’t seem like a casual hookup kinda guy at all and hooking up with a girl who is also friends with his ex-wife? Seemed so grimey for Brendan.
“What? I told you I didn’t want to tell you,” he said when I looked at him with disgust.

“So who is the friend? What’s her name?” I asked because I would absolutely be deepdiving into her social’s later.
Brendan refused to tell me who it was, claimed it wasn’t serious — they’d just ran into each other randomly at the Gansevoort Rooftop and hung out a few times, and then he wanted to know how many people I hooked up with to deflect. I proudly told him none (because I didn’t get a chance to). And you could tell by the look on his face, that he wished he hadn’t revealed his hookups with me.
Don’t ask me how, but I figured out who the girl was. “Lily.”
Okay, I’ll tell you how. So Brendan is not typically secretive and I have the passcode for his phone. I don’t typically go through it because I trust him, but with this new information I had the urge to go through his phone to investigate for myself. So while he was in the shower one evening, I picked up his phone off the charger and got to work. Lucky for me, Brendan doesn’t ever delete his messages (I don’t either – you just never know) and I searched “Gansevoort” in his messages and quickly narrowed my search down to “Lily” — who looked positively slutty in her contact photo (brunette with a slick back and a drink in her hand).
I quickly realized that she was who I was looking for as I scrolled through their message thread and big text blocks between them had kissy face and heart emojis. Brendan described their relationship as “nothing serious” but as I was reading the messages, I felt another crashout coming. His messages to her were like, “You know how much you mean to me,” and “I care about you, you’re so special,” etc. You know, typical Brendan-isms. Definitely not things you’d say to a casual hookup. I even saw messages from her voicing concerns about how serious they were getting. And his replies saying things like, “I can’t help how I’m feeling, I feel like I falling I’m love with you.”
I felt really stupid. Like I’d been duped. I hadn’t even heard of this girl and he was supposedly falling in love with her? It was insane to me that he was in a situation where he had such strong feelings just months before we got together and then he started saying the same kind of shit to me! What the fuck? With him moving on so fast after his divorce, first with “Lily” and then me, it made it seem like he was trying to just fill a void and I was the fucking idiot who fell into the trap. Was our whole relationship a farce? If you recall, I’d even voiced similar concerns as “Lily” about how fast he/we were moving.
I calmly locked the phone and put it back where I found it. I should have never gone through his phone and if I hadn’t I would not have known that stale, four year old tea.
But you know me. I couldn’t just keep my findings to myself — I brought it up the moment he got out of the shower.
“How was your shower?” I asked, eye twitching.
“I wish you would’ve joined me,” Brendan said.
“I was already clean,” I said and then, “So you said your little fling before we got together wasn’t serious? Your fling with ‘Lily?’”
“Uh…no, not really. How do you know about that?” he asked, confused.
I pointed to his phone. “I saw it in your phone and it seemed serious to me.”
“You should not have done that,” Brendan said, like I am five years old.
“Obviously, but I did and now I’m questioning everything because I feel like our entire relationship is a lie.”
“What?”
I explained to him how weird I thought it was that he’d gotten serious with both me and “Lily” so soon after his divorce, how I thought I was special, but maybe he was just looking for his replacement wife.
“What the fuck, Reese?”
He was clearly getting upset, but I couldn’t stop. I was upset too and he just stood there looking at me and once again did nothing to reassure me. I accused him of lovebombing me (and “Lily”) and told him that he probably should’ve taken some time to himself to be single after his divorce.
“So what are you saying? You don’t want to be in this relationship anymore?” Brendan asked, looking like he was going to cry.
“No! Obviously not, if that’s what I wanted then I would’ve said that! I’m giving you a chance to explain yourself because right now it seems like you moved too fast with her, she pulled away so then you tried the same thing with me,” I said back.
“I actually can’t believe you,” he said and that was the last thing he said to me for four days.
Our fight happened on a Wednesday night and the timing sucked because Brendan was leaving the next evening for a trip with his college friends to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day in Chicago. “Like old times.” The trip had been in the works for weeks at that point and I knew we weren’t going to resolve anything before he left because I was mad at him for shutting down when I confronted him about “Lily” and then not even cuddling me while we were in bed!
After work, I went and got Winnie from school and we ran our afternoon errands before heading back home. I was in the kitchen making dinner when I heard Brendan come home and greet Winnie, who was in the living room watching TV. I waited patiently for him to come and say hi to me, but then I heard him walk down the hallway without even breathing in my direction! I was definitely feeling some PTSD from my relationship with Brady when he would stonewall me when we were fighting. I just never thought Brendan would be like that. Like, fuck you! I was mad all over again.
He didn’t have dinner with us because he was doing a Peloton ride, I later found out. After I put Winnie to sleep, I found Brendan in the bedroom, freshly showered and zipping up his stupid fucking carryon for his trip. We made eye contact and he didn’t say anything, but looked at me like he expected me to say something.
“Enjoy your trip, I guess. I hope you don’t end up in the river,” I said dryly.
Brendan had the nerve to look hurt by my comment, but still didn’t say anything! It’s like, did you lose your voice? What’s wrong with you? And then he just fucking left, without even saying goodbye to me! The fuck? I understand that he didn’t like me going through his phone or the lovebombing accusations and he was mad about that, but I was mad first and he was the one who needed to explain himself! After he left, I had a mini crashout alone before staying up until 4am crying.
That weekend, my mom came back to stay for a few weeks. I hadn’t been well since Brendan left on Thursday evening and even though the last thing I wanted was for her to meddle in my relationship, I was dying to talk to someone about it. So I relayed the entire story to her (beginning with the Miami trip when I got in trouble for “flirting” with the 25 year old) in great detail until I ended up bawling with my head in my hands.
“First of all,” she said, prying my hands away from face. “You need to get into therapy.”
My mom hasn’t tried to force me into therapy like that since high school so I knew things must be bad. And I knew that she was right because I didn’t want to feel the way I was feeling and despite everything, I wanted my relationship with Brendan to work.
So she went into full mom-mode and made a list of therapists for me and then contacted them about availability to see me. Then we went to dinner where she let me know all the ways in which I was wrong in my fight with Brendan. I always take my mom’s relationship advice with a grain of salt because she is very male centered and her greatest accomplishment in life is being married to my dad despite the fact they should’ve divorced years ago. But that’s neither here nor there!
Brendan came home on Sunday evening. We hadn’t spoken at all while he was away on his trip and even though I missed him, I still kinda had the ick about the entire situation. But still, when he got home, we hugged and kissed like nothing was the matter. Typical Brendan and Reese type of shit.
“I missed you. Do you want to hear about my trip?” Brendan asked and I told him that I did so he sat and chatted with me and my mom for a while telling us everything that happened. As much as I wanted to be standoffish and give him nothing, as I sat there listening to him and watching him, I realized that all I wanted was for things to go back to normal between us. And everything would have been fine if I didn’t have the knowledge about “Lily” and I wouldn’t have had that knowledge if I hadn’t made Brendan tell me about her and if I hadn’t gone through his phone. What’s the saying about how the genie can’t be put back in the bottle or whatever? I don’t know, but please let this be a lesson to you and me both that nothing good ever comes from going through your partner’s phone. I will never do it again.
Eventually Brendan excused himself to go unpack and once he was out of sight, my mom offered to mediate our imminent confrontation. I’m like, that’s literally the last thing I want — you can actually leave.
When I got the bedroom, Brendan said, “I didn’t end up in the river,” as a joke.
“Oh,” I said, not even cracking a smile.
He pulled me into a hug and held me for a moment before saying, “I’m sorry. I don’t want to fight with you.”
“Same,” I said.
Brendan said that he was ready to explain himself and said that space was good for both of us. He’s like, “I’m not mad about you snooping, I don’t care about that. I was just frustrated because that was not information or a situation I was prepared to talk about with you.”
“Mmhm.” I nodded.
He explained that he understood why I did what I did since he wasn’t exactly forthcoming with the information, but my words hurt and made him feel embarrassed and ashamed, but after taking time to think, he felt better. And then he apologized again for shutting down.. He didn’t offer any additional information about “Lily” or their situation — which I guess is fine — but then he wanted to know how I felt. I’m sure it helped that he had four whole days to think about it, but I thought Brendan did such a good job articulating how he felt. It’s almost exactly how I felt during the Florida/25 year old situation (the embarrassment and shame of it all); I just couldn’t explain it to him in the moment. I don’t know, I guess he just has a way with his words because then he reaffirmed how he felt about me and how he has never questioned his feelings for me and they have never wavered, etc. He even said something along the lines of, “I knew I had strong feelings for you when I shouldn’t have…”
At the end of the conversation, I felt a lot better: everything Brendan said made sense to me and I’d certainly learned my lesson so I was ready to move on from the situation and continue planning our wedding!
But then. We were smooth sailing for approximately one month and then Brendan did it again. I mentioned that we’ve been hanging out with other couples (couples from Brendan’s circle and some of my mom friends) and we were out at a restaurant bar with a big group one night. It was Brendan and me plus: Miguel and Jasmine; Kendall and his new-ish GF who is serious about; Brendan’s HS friends, Jordan and Benny and their significant others; and then I invited a mom I’m friends with from Winnie’s school, Kelli, and her husband, Matt. Brendan and I had hung out with Kelli and Matt a few times at school functions without any issue and we all got along fine. Matt is my age and Kelli is like four or five years old and they’re both super into health and fitness in an almost problematic way. His Instagram is filled with quotes about how we are killing our bodies with chemicals, food is the enemy and MAHA with explicitly saying “MAHA.” But still, they like to drink and they’re always a fun time so it’s whatever.
Anywho, Matt and I have a similar sense of humor and I joke around with him like I do with literally everyone else. I’m not sure what was in the water that night, but I guess Brendan suddenly had an issue with the way I was speaking to Matt – who I could not be less attracted to if I tried. Without completely dragging his appearance, he is sort of…roidy and bald and has no eyebrows (perhaps a side effect of all the supplements). All of that is besides the point because I was legitimately not doing anything wrong.
Brendan tapped me and said, “Really? Can you stop?”
Since I wasn’t doing anything bad, I turned to him and nodded and then went right back to what I was doing (talking to Kelli and Matt). Unbeknownst to me, Brendan’s issue was with me talking to Matt in general. We stayed for about an hour longer and everyone was talking about going to another spot to continue drinking. Brendan wanted to go home.
“Why? You’re so boringgggg,” I whined as he paid our bill. I had my arms dangling around his neck and he pried me off and told me to stop. Wow, so he was clearly in a mood and I didn’t push it.
In the car on the way home, he let me know that he didn’t like the way I was acting with Matt, accused me of being “all over him” and it made him uncomfortable. And then he started in on the whole, “If you respected me and our relationship,” lecture. I’m just like, Matt? Matt?? Respectfully, the man looks like a thumb. What the actual fuck? But this time I didn’t cry or crashout – I was just so confused as I was not flirting with that man.
“What? How exactly was I ‘all over him?’” I asked and I know it came out bitchily. I was trying to hear him out even though in the back of my mind I knew he was being unreasonable.
“Flirting with him, laughing at everything he says, not paying attention to anyone else. You don’t think it’s weird?” Brendan said, in a tone like it was obvious.
“Okay,” I said, calmly. “I actually don’t, but I’m sorry for making you feel disrespected. I don’t understand what I did, but I’ll try not to do it again.”
I was about to lose my fucking mind. I just felt so confused and defeated. Not that I was bad before, but I had been on my best behavior since we had our other two little hiccups. And it seemed to me like Brendan was extra possessive ever since we got engaged and was always trying to find a problem with me. I didn’t think I’d ever given him any reason not to trust me, I have always been my gregarious — perhaps slightly flirty — self and it was odd to me that he was just now bringing up that he didn’t like it and it made him uncomfortable. And the men he was accusing me of flirting with were so not anything to be concerned about. In fact, it was almost offensive. It was also confusing to me that he was offended by the way I behaved around other *random* men, but was completely unbothered by my relationship with his two close friends, Kendall and Miguel, which were arguably more inappropriate/flirty than any of the situations he’d gotten mad at me for. And if we were being really, really honest, I was the one who should be acting possessive and irrational after the whole “Lily” situation/revelation. I don’t know. It’s like, just because we are engaged doesn’t mean you get to own me. And I don’t want to turn into one of those girls who can’t make eye contact with men because my husband doesn’t like it, you know?
Y’all! I’ll be back with a more lighthearted post soon! Don’t worry – Brendan and I are good and we are still getting married (hopefully)! I can’t wait to share more!